My rating: 3 of 5 stars
The concept is just super original and cool! Execution was good for middle grade readers but a bit lacking in terms of mature themes for young adult audiences. I personally have no problem with the storyline because it was nicely crafted and neatly played out. Nothing was written for convenience’s sake and everything happened for a purpose. The basic formula for fantasy was very obvious with the plot device aka the needle and the quest to save the world. Despite all this, it didn’t detract me from enjoying the plot.
“Slipping quietly into her soft bed and feeling the down of her countless pillows, Tyra blew out her candle, pulled the long silk sheets up to her chin, and closed her eyes for the night. Her thoughts lingered on Arek as she listened to the quiet.”
What really irked me, however, was the writing. It wasn’t outright terrible but I felt the vocabulary was too juvenile and the wording of sentences were oftentimes awkward. The writing style was especially descriptive but the adjectives were clichéd/overused and that’s not necessarily a bad thing but there’s only so many times a simple words can be used. It created an amateurish feeling and there were better alternatives that can easily replace “Her heart raced.” and
“With a flabbergasted frown, the scullion reclaimed the meal and dashed back into the kitchens. Tyra cried for him to stop, but he was too quick, and she watched as her beautiful meal vanished behind the swinging door. She stared at the peasant with a look of severe contempt.”
There’s a lot of mixing of past-tense and present-tense actions in the same sentence and it may be grammatically correct but still very ill-fitting. It’s not well-written in terms of eloquence and it’s poorly labelled as ‘young adult’ and it’s a terrible choice to market it to YA audiences. I’m not sure how to describe it exactly but since it’s the author’s début, Woven as an entirety needs improvement and lacks the refinement/polishing that accompanies many books.
“A loud crack, like the splitting of a tree branch, sounded behind Arek. Tyra [the princess] watched as the knight’s hazel eyes rolled back. He slumped forward and fell on top of her. Shrieking, Tyra struggled to free herself. Their picnic basket tipped on its side, spilling its contents onto the blanket. Her heart quivering, she stood up and looked over her love, lying unconscious on the ground.”
The romance was also very unconvincing and although I’m satisfied that it wasn’t highly prioritized, it played a major role in the reason for embarking on the whole journey. The interactions between the princess and the peasant was wholly boring and there was nothing that spiced it up for me. I did not feel the infatuation and there were positive characteristics to each character but they were not flattering in the romantic sense. That part really fell flat for me and that particularly harmed the book. The chemistry was nonexistent. There was no effort to set up vulnerable, emotional scenes that bonded the duo aside from just basic constant proximity and unity through a common mission. In all cases, it wouldn’t have made any difference if they were pitched as siblings instead of a couple.
Don’t get me wrong though, the premise and idea of threads that intertwine everyone’s lives has a fresh twist of originality and the writing is easy to breeze through.The writing may not be good enough to qualify as YA but it’s not too juvenile for middle grade readers. So any of you middle schoolers that are searching for an entertaining tale, look no further and sit down with Woven. The weak romance in this scenario may actually be a positive and work out well to please younglings whose attention will be enraptured by a simplistic fantasy of questing.
Give this book a try to see if it’s to your liking but those who crave heavier and darker themes will do best to shy away. Mature high fantasy books by Joe Abercrombie, Melina Marchetta, Garth Nix, Brandon Sanderson, Pierce Brown, and Patrick Rothfuss is where all the goodie’s at.
For great middle grade fantasy, find these authors:
Rick Riordan, Diana Wynne Jones, Eva Ibbotson, Brandon Mull, Nancy Farmer, Neil Gaiman, Marie Rutkoski’s first series, Shannon Hale, Gail Carson Levine, and of course, J.K. Rowling.
Thank you Scholastic from Edelweiss for providing me with a copy of this book.